‘A Good Decision’ or ‘Travesty of Justice’? Christians React to Trump’s Execution Livestream Reversal

Audio By Carbonatix

The Trump administration has changed course, with President Trump announcing that a military execution will no longer be livestreamed; many Christians applauded the decision, but not all were in agreement with the president’s move.

On Thursday morning, Trump took to social media to announce his administration’s reversal of the plan to livestream the execution of the Fort Hood shooter, Nidal Hasan. Hasan was convicted of killing 13 and injuring more than 30 people in the 2009 shooting, and was later sentenced to death. 

The president posted on Truth Social, writing, “Many very good and well meaning people would rather not watch him die, through streaming, or through any other visual device.”

Following the president’s announcement, a handful of recognizable names and faces in the Christian world took to social media to express their agreement with Trump’s change in course.

Christian conservative radio host Erick Erickson called it “a good decision.”

“Not live streaming the Nidal Hassan execution is a good decision,” Erickson wrote on X/Twitter. “Many of those who claim they just want to see justice really just want to see a snuff film they can meme.”

Clare Anne Ath, regional director of government affairs for the Human Coalition and a Catholic, agreed with Trump’s decision, calling it the “right call.”

“We have a serious problem in this country with turning death and violence into entertainment and live-streaming an execution would only make it worse,” she wrote.

“Human dignity doesn’t disappear because someone commits evil,” she continued. “Rejecting the culture of death means rejecting it even when it’s unpopular.”

Matthew Lee Anderson, a teacher at Baylor University and the founder of Mere Orthodoxy, also believes that canceling the livestream was the right move.

 “This is clearly the right choice and President Trump should be commended for making it,” he posted.

However, not everyone agreed with the president’s decision to cancel the livestream. Ben Zeisloft, a Christian and the communications director for Foundation to Abolish Abortion, said Trump’s decision was a “travesty of justice.”

“President Donald Trump canceling the public execution of an Islamic terrorist is a travesty of justice,” he wrote. “While the execution will proceed, making the execution private only projects weakness, but fails to deter other evildoers with the threat of severe punishment.”

Additionally, some were not entirely sure where they stood on the president’s announcement.

“I was never sure whether live streaming was the right choice or not,” Jackie Chea, an evangelical Christian and blogger, posted. “I’m not sure there was a correct or incorrect outcome in that regard. The important thing is that the execution ensures justice and deters future traitorous, murderous, terrorist acts.”

Despite the cancellation of the livestream, Trump, in his social media post, made it clear that he felt there was value in making Hasan’s execution by firing squad available for public consumption.

“I think streaming the execution for all to see might have been a strong deterrent for the World to witness how America deals with Terrorists and SCUM like Hasan,” Trump wrote.

Photo Credit: ©Getty Images/Ian Maule/Stringer