Healing Your Attachment Styles as a Married Couple – II
Ministries > Focus on the Family with Jim Daly
Have you ever wondered why you and your spouse respond so differently to conflict? Marc and Amy Cameron explain how your attachment styles can shape the way you communicate, connect, and handle challenges in marriage. Discover practical ways to heal from past wounds and build a stronger relationship!
Jim Daly: After 10 years of living with addiction and anger, Kimberly was ready to give up on her marriage and family, but God used our ministry to transform her heart.
Guest (Female): The podcast and all the Focus on the Family resources was like the hands and feet of Jesus in that moment.
Jim Daly: I'm Jim Daly. Somewhere there's a prodigal running out of time. Let's deliver hope and joy to them. Give and your gift will be doubled at focusonthefamily.com/family.
Announcer: This program is sponsored by Focus on the Family, and your generosity brings hope to families every day.
Mark Cameron: Well, why would I want to feel sad? Why would I want to feel worried? Who wants to feel that way? The problem is, is if you can't selectively suppress emotions. So if you suppress emotions, you suppress all emotions, and that stops you from being able to connect with another person because you don't have an emotional experience to connect with, with the other person, because the definition of empathy is I know what it feels like for you because I know what it feels like for me, but if I don't know that, then I can't enter into your experience.
John Fuller: Well, that's Mark Cameron, and he and his wife Amy join us today on Focus on the Family with Jim Daly. They're going to offer tools that you as a couple can use to develop secure relationships. Thanks for joining us. I'm John Fuller.
Jim Daly: You know, John, this attachment style thing captivates me because to me it shows design. It's like one of those things like Love Languages by Gary Chapman or The Birth Order by Kevin Lehman. They're seeing models of predictable behavior because of something, right? your birth order. These are generalities, but they generally fit. For the firstborn, you tend to be responsible, last born, party animal, kind of highly social. Those kinds of things are maybe that 80-20 rule, and it explains a bit as to why you developed the way you developed, right? Attachment styles are very similar, but deeper. It's about the personality that God has given you and how you have framed your life and how it's informed you from being an infant until now. And as we talked about yesterday with Mark and Amy, you have about 20 years of that formation. That's a lot of training that goes on, and sometimes we don't even know why we react the way we react and what kind of person we have developed into and those areas that we need to grow in. And I think this is not only biblical and Christian, but very informative about how to become a secure attached person, which is the goal.
John Fuller: Yeah, because so often we get into a relationship and especially in marriage, there's such intensity and we go back to the same patterns. And that's why the our guests and the resource are so important. Mark and Amy have a blended family with two young adult kids, and they minister to couples through the organization How We Love. And Mark is a licensed marriage and family therapist, and he's written a new book called Understanding Your Attachment Style: The Path to Overcoming Unhelpful Patterns and Building Healthy, Secure Relationships. And it's our goal to bring you great content in the show, but we can't cover everything in the book, so contact us and get a copy of this book from Focus on the Family today. We've got the details at focusonthefamily.com/broadcast.
Jim Daly: Mark and Amy, welcome back. Thank you. Day 2 of brutal examination of my soul. No, I love it. This is really, hopefully you have an appetite to grow. That's part of the, I think, part of the Christian belief system. You know, you want to get closer to God, right? And do a better job becoming more like him. And part of that's just knowing what is true, which in this world can be hard to do. We get kind of blurry eyed when it comes to us and our behavior patterns and are we causing pain, et cetera. But welcome back.
Unidentified Speaker: Thank you.
Mark Cameron: Thank you for having us.
Jim Daly: We talked about the avoider last time. You got a little insight on me there. We're going to continue through the types, and the next one that I wanted to talk about was the pleaser, and I do have a general impression that a lot of people do fit this category. I think in the Christian community particularly, it sounds like kindness, it sounds like love to be a pleaser. That's probably one of the most difficult things for the pleaser, because you're thinking, you know, I'm doing a good thing. I'm laying my life down for my neighbor. The scripture says to do that. Is it healthy?
Mark Cameron: For the pleaser, the wound for the pleaser is learning to manage other people's emotions and losing themselves. And so, yes, while we're called to lay our lives down for others, to be kind, to be loving, to be giving, what's happening for the pleaser, though, is they're losing themselves in the process. They become codependent. They manage other people's emotions, often to their detriment, because it's really about managing the anxiety on the inside for them. So it can tend to be quite disingenuous, their caretaking of other people, because it's more about for them to feel better on the inside. So on the outside, it looks like they're doing a good thing, but when they don't have boundaries, when they can't say no, when they become enmeshed with other people. That doesn't serve other people because when you rescue others when they could recover and grow from that, you prevent their growth from happening. What's the childhood environment that develops the pleaser? What did those folks go through that gave them that behavior? Yeah, so they grow up in a home being trained how to do this. They have a parent who is angry and that anger scares them, or they have a highly critical parent, or an anxious or worried parent, or chronically depressed parent. And because children need their parents to help them calm down and soothe, if you have a dysregulated parent, what this child learns how to do is, if I am just not an additional stressor, I can then calm them down. And a pleaser tries to predict their parents' mood to get them regulated so that they can feel regulated. We learn how to self-soothe first by being co-soothed. And what the pleaser does is they learn just how to co-soothe other people. And so when they grow up and they go into adulthood, you know, they're taking other people's emotional temperatures. How are you doing? Is everything okay? Can I get you a drink? But they lose themselves because you ask the pleaser, well, where do you want to go eat? And they'll default to you. Well, where do you want to go eat? I want you to be happy. And they think they don't really care, but in order to know your likes and preferences, you have to learn how to explore them. And other times they think, well, I don't want you to be upset, but or I want you to be happy, but really it's they don't want you to be upset. Because when you get upset, it causes anxiety on the inside for them.
Jim Daly: And I think it's so important, the veil that can look like you're doing a good thing and even behaving like a Christian should behave. I think that's so important. I don't put myself in that category, but I could see the conflict of that. Like, you know, I'm trying to be a good Christian, and this, in this codependency kind of thing, I'm being that good Christian by not having a preference. You tell me what you want to do, and we'll go do it, but you aren't being honest. Is that fair? Is it an honesty thing with your own heart?
Mark Cameron: I think it's fair, but a lot of the times the police just don't realize this. These things tend to be housed in the unconscious part of our mind, so we don't realize that we're engaging in these strategies, and we will justify our strategies because otherwise it creates a discrepancy in our mind between our values and our actions. And so we have to bring those two in alignment, and most of the times we'll change our thinking to match our behaviors rather than changing our behaviors to match developing thinking and grow, and that's how growth occurs. When we are able to see these attachment styles and see that they're wounds from our childhood and be able to compare that with secure attachment, changes our thinking, and then that's how growth occurs, because then we change our behavior to match our thinking rather than the other way around.
Jim Daly: Just sticking with the pleaser for a minute, then we'll get into vacillator and the others. What are some of the common conflicts that come up for those in relationship with a pleaser, the spouse who's married a pleaser. Amy, what are some of those things to begin to say, wow, okay, we got to move?
Amy Cameron: Well, I think the alarming thing for me about the pleaser that I've learned in this work is pleasers don't get angry till they're about 40 or 50, and then they're like, when's it going to be my turn? Because they've been waiting, and they've been waiting, and they've been help, you know, and if there is an affair with the pleaser, that's one of the hardest marriages to win back. And so that's kind of a frightening theory about the pleaser. So it's like, you know, like if you keep suppressing your needs and keep suppressing your needs, like, you know, like what's that going to look like in temptation when somebody's actually wanting to lean into your needs?
Jim Daly: Mark, how would you encourage a pleaser to set goals to get out of that rhythm, that pattern?
Mark Cameron: So pleasers need to learn how to have a voice. Generally, pleasers can be over committed because they don't know how to say no because they don't want to let other people down, or they don't have strong boundaries to stand up for themselves when somebody is being unreasonable or somebody is angry. They get triggered around conflict and separation, and so they need to learn, how do I have a no? How do I have boundaries? Jesus was able to have a no. He was able to be strong. He was able to push back against the Pharisees when he knew that they were trying to trap him, or he was able to say, I'm not going to perform this miracle here because you're just wanting me to perform a trick rather than to believe in me. And so he had strong boundaries. He didn't give in to what everybody wanted, even though he came down to serve other people. And pleasers need to learn how to do that so that they can learn how to have a voice, and when you have a voice, it creates balance in a relationship.
Jim Daly: Yeah. That attunement factor you mentioned last time, just describe that again and the importance of attunement and what does it mean?
Mark Cameron: Yeah, attunement is being able to understand what emotions are driving your behaviors and what emotions are driving other people's behaviors and how that physically and mentally and emotionally impacts them. And so when we're able to perceive that in other people, we can lean in and we can look underneath what someone's saying to what their emotional state actually is.
Jim Daly: Yeah. Emotional intelligence is also part of this, Amy, especially aimed at your spouse. I remember this was a really hard-hitting comment a friend of mine made, like we were just talking about marriage generally, and he said, well, let me ask you a question. With Jean, my wife, do you prepare like you would for a broadcast to ask her questions? no, but what an interesting thing for me as a challenge as her husband. Do I spend the time thinking about her where she's at as I would a broadcast taping, to create my own prep for engagement with Jean at the end of the day. Hey, what did you do today? How did that make you feel? Did that hurt when your friend said that to you? You know, questions I would ask here. Isn't that, that's pretty insightful and a good admonition of my friend to me, you know, treat your wife no less than you would a broadcast guest. Wow. What do you think of that, Amy?
Amy Cameron: Yeah, I think having emotional intelligence allows us to go deeper with our spouse. So we want to increase intimacy, we want to increase connection, we want to increase comfort. We can't stay up here on the surface. What'd you have for lunch today? Like, we need to go deeper. Having a framework of the comfort circle, which is just slowing down the conversation. Well, how did that make you feel? Like, opening to the back of the book and like, give me three feeling words. Like, that just kind of teases out the dialogue a little bit more to understand, well, how did you feel when you were 7? How did you feel when you're 8? And, you know, understanding more about your spouse or any special relationship that you're close to, like, at a younger age, like, draws out more comfort, and it creates opportunity for these painful experiences to be comforted with your spouse.
Jim Daly: You know, I can only imagine, and again, this isn't gender oriented, but typically a husband's hearing this going, you know, it just, I got bills to pay, I got things to do. This sounds like a big homework assignment to try to figure out what my style, attachment style is, what's my wife's, and I can barely carry the load I'm carrying right now, but the reward is big. I mean, if you invest this way, spend the time, do the prep for your wife, there's a big payback, right, Mark?
Mark Cameron: Well, if you... everybody has an attachment style, and so whether you recognize it or not, it's going to highly influence the way that you relate with other people. And so these are learned skills. If we had a parent who was able to draw us out, ask us thoughtful questions, make observations about how we feel, then you grow up and these are practice skills that you've learned how to do. But if you haven't learned how to do that, then you've got to learn how to practice, and practice is intentional. I like to say that. Nobody ever fell into a good relationship by accident, right? Good relationships happen on purpose, and they're created, they're cultivated, and they take specific growth work to do.
John Fuller: Well, good stuff, today that we're unpacking on Focus on the Family with Jim Daly. Our guests are Mark and Amy Cameron, and Mark has written this terrific book. It's so good. It's called Understanding Your Attachment Style: The Path to Overcoming Unhelpful Patterns and Building Healthy, Secure Relationships. And we'll encourage you to stop by our website to get a copy of the book, and that's focusonthefamily.com/broadcast.
Jim Daly: Amy, the early years of your marriage included a lot of anger because you both came into the marriage as vacillators. So maybe we need to describe vacillator and then describe your own struggles as a vacillator.
Amy Cameron: Yeah, vacillator imprint comes from a home where there's inconsistent connection. And so, you know, my story is, unfortunately, my dad committed suicide when I was 7, and then my mom fell into addictions, boyfriend after boyfriend, and
Mark Cameron: Wow.
Amy Cameron: So there was just that abrupt inconsistency. So, you know, dreaming as a child, hoping, you know, like, I idealized and got married at 18, thinking that marriage was gonna kind of fix things, but that high hope went to addiction and deep disappointment, and that ended in divorce. And so, like, that was another attachment injury for me. And so, I was a single mom with Caitlin when I married Mark, and he had Carter, he was a Christian, you know, he had his career going, and we got married rather quickly, in that idealization phase, like probably before our first conflict, wouldn't you say? And so, when we had our first conflict, like, it was like fireworks, you know, vacillator, vacillator equals volcano. So it was just we did not know how to fight, and I could tell just based on, you know, like the Gottman's research, how you fight will predict whether or not your marriage survives or not.
Jim Daly: Wow.
Amy Cameron: Like contempt, stonewalling, and that was the pattern for me, and that was the pattern that I learned, you know, from my mom, like, let's just not talk for 2 days and stonewall, and then 2 days later act like everything's okay, and that's damaging, damaging, damaging. And so, you know, thankfully, this attachment work helped us to look within and find out what those triggers are, because, like you said, anger is an indicator. Like, my step one is when I felt the anger, I had to go beneath, like, what is the underlying need here? And, like, asking for that need to be met is vulnerability, because for the vacillator, like, if you ask and the need is not met, you could feel even more disappointed or more vulnerable, but I also had to acknowledge when he would come near to me and I would push him away because I'm angry, I needed to come back and repair, like, "Hey, like, I was activated, I was angry, and, like, you know, like, I need to- I need to receive that, you know, back. So, you know, like, these are really, um, things that you can really see, these patterns. So, like, I encourage you to study them and understand what your triggers are. So Mark has a great acronym, Mud Wars, and I think he-
Jim Daly: It's a great acronym.
Guest (Male): TV show.
Amy Cameron: But, but it helped me understand, OK, anger, what's under the anger? Mud Wars, OK, what is the need, and go from there.
Jim Daly: What are the Mud Wars?
Mark Cameron: So the Mud Wars are, these are the major ways the vacillator gets triggered when they feel misunderstood, that's the M, unseen or unheard, that's the U. When they get disappointed, when they're made to wait, especially for time, attention, and connection. When they perceive abandonment or perceive rejection, that's the A and the R. So it's not really real abandonment or real rejection, it's perceived. So if I come home from the gym and I go to hug Amy and she's like, well, can you take a shower first? That's a perceived rejection. Or if I make dinner for the family and then everybody leaves me with a cleanup, that's a perceived rejection. And so these things happen all the time for the vacillator. And then the last one is shame. Shame from feeling rejected, I don't feel good enough, or shame from making a mistake. Vacillators go to a deep place of shame that others usually don't know about. And so as I developed this acronym and I learned that when I got triggered, instead of getting angry, if I looked underneath, I was able to identify what was going on.
Jim Daly: That's a pretty powerful list for the spouse. I mean, Wow, you're constantly in trouble. You know, you don't know what to say because, you know, and, you know, I think many of us can feel that, that sense of shame rise up when you say, wow, the chicken's a little cold. Wham! Like, that defines who I am, whoever's making it, the guy or the girl. How could you say the chicken is cold? I have spent all day making that chicken. but I mean, that's how that thing will.
Mark Cameron: Well, these kinds of things happen all the time, right? The conflicts that people have are generally about largely innocuous stuff, you know, very minor things, but it triggers a wound on the inside that you're not aware of. And so I had to, how I grew is I was able to identify these two things, and as they were happening, I started to see it, and then that challenged me to grow out of that.
Jim Daly: So when you say you started to see it, that's seeing the pattern of what was happening.
Mark Cameron: Correct, and so that was the way to stop it from being so automatic. And having to interrupt that cycle and then lean into the growth goals that I had to lean out of it.
Jim Daly: So that's vacillator. There's two what you term disorganized attachment styles. What are they?
Mark Cameron: So that's a research word, the disorganized attachment style. So that's someone who grows up in a home where the home is dangerous. There's abuse, there's neglect, or they're exposed, either by the parent or they're exposed to this environment. And so needs basically get reduced to survival. And oftentimes these kids, they leave the home very early, 14, 15, 16 years old. They get out of there as soon as possible. And what happens is, is they can grow up and go into adulthood and just have a mix of these attachment styles because they try everything and different things work at different times. Or they realize that relationships are this, a one up, one down. You know, there's an abuser and there's somebody who
Jim Daly: A victim.
Mark Cameron: gets abused, yeah, the victim. And so the controller says, well, I'm not going to be in the one down position, so I'm going to control my environment for predictability, for me to be safe, and I control my environment by controlling others. Or the victim learns that, abuse happens to me, I can't stop it, I'm helpless, but eventually it goes away. And so they try and stay under the radar, and these two folks generally find one another in adulthood because that's the relationship pattern is familiar to them and they end up in the cycle of abuse.
Jim Daly: So is there a corollary there in terms of that victim to where they end up in relationships because there's something that they are looking for or they tolerate abuse or somehow that, tell me what's happening in that situation.
Mark Cameron: Yeah, usually abusive relationships don't start off as abusive. Usually there's a love bombing phase where the other person's, really taking care of them, really wanting to provide for them, and that feels safe for them. But what's happening, if they meet somebody who's more abusive, is that person's actually creating a dependency upon them. And then later on, when the abuse starts to happen, they feel isolated. They feel dependent upon the other person, either financially or, sometimes spiritual abuse occurs where they believe that they have to stay, they can't leave. And then the relationship then is familiar for what they grew up with. And so really, a lot of people can actually give up on the victim. Friends or counselors can, and it takes a lot of time to really build that relationship, to teach them how to be empowered or teach them that they can get to safety.
Jim Daly: Right, and there is hope. Amy, for that person listening that might be living in that spot right now, they're hearing this going, wow, that is who I am as I hear you describe it. Is there hope in Christ?
Amy Cameron: I think sometimes, like in the church, oh, you know, like stay married, you know, like is
John Fuller: God hates divorce.
Amy Cameron: God hates divorce and all of that, but if you are being abused, God does not want you to be abused. And so, but God wants you to be set free from that. And can you heal? Yes, but what requires healing is two individuals willing to grow. And you need to create the space in a safe way to do that.
Jim Daly: Well, let me, you know, ratchet that in a slightly different direction, that it's not that kind of environment of safety, but for the spouse that says, I'm doing a good job, but my husband, he's not moving with me. I'm doing what I need to do, but he doesn't do what he needs to do. Which one do you want to jump on that?
Mark Cameron: Well, so that's exactly why I've written the book, is this book is about learning how do you identify your attachment style and how do you learn to grow? Because when we learn to grow, we give people a different response that they have to manage. And so if I'm used to getting into arguments with my spouse and I get into the growth process, I might learn to say something like, I can see that this is important to you, but I'm not willing to argue about it. I'm going to check back with you in 10 minutes and see if we can have a productive conversation about it. Well, wow, rather than engaging in the conflict, you've given them something else to think about, and you've created or you're creating an environment where you can have a productive conversation and rather than stay stuck in the conflict.
Jim Daly: Yeah, it's so good. I'm thinking of 2 snapshots. You remember the old Polaroid instant picture? You could do this on your phone now, but, you know, if you take that snapshot of an argument you might have in the first 2, 3 years of your marriage, boom, all the emotion, all the anger, everything you've talked about these last 2 days is right there. And then with that secure attachment, which is the goal, saying the thing that you just said, take that snapshot, what a marked difference that is in your relationship, in your soul, and how you operate with those around you, right? That's the goal.
Mark Cameron: Yeah, and if you can understand the trigger, the childhood wound underneath it, one, you don't hold the other person as the cause of the feeling inside of you, and it helps depersonalize for the other person what's happening in your spouse. Because you know, okay, they got triggered, and if you know the childhood story behind that, you can have empathy for that.
Jim Daly: Yeah, it's so true. Let's end here, the idea of forgiveness. We haven't mentioned that yet, and that's critical in marriage and relationships, the ability to truly forgive. What does that look like?
Mark Cameron: So I have a whole chapter on forgiveness, and in the chapter I differentiate between something called decisional forgiveness and emotional forgiveness. Okay, so emotional forgiveness is I feel like forgiving. Decisional forgiveness is I'm making a conscious choice to forgive someone, and the research shows that we often have to make that conscious choice of decisional forgiveness over and over and over again before that feeling of emotional forgiveness follows. But the interesting thing about forgiveness is, is that it's as much as for the forgiver's benefit as it is for the person being forgiven, because when we recall a memory and we can recall it from a place of forgiveness, it actually changes that memory in your brain. And so every time you remember that event, if you can have a reparative experience with your spouse, if you can learn how to talk about your childhood stories and the wounds that you didn't receive comfort from and receive them in this relationship, it actually heals that and that trigger reduces and makes you less reactive.
Jim Daly: Yeah, wow, this has been so good. This is amazing. I mean, these are the things to really think about. I said it before, but, understand who Jesus was and get your faith set as the foundation and then figure out who you are. and this is a great way to do it through understanding your attachment styles. what a beautiful way to follow that journey to get to a healthier place in life where you want to be, right? Thanks for being with us.
Mark Cameron: Thanks for having us.
Jim Daly: So good, and I hope you feel equipped to face the difficulties in your marriage. no matter what has happened in your past, God can heal and restore your relationship. We at Focus on the Family want to be part of that. So if our program today felt heavy because you are struggling in your marriage, look into attending Hope Restored. Couples who participate in that go through a 4-day intensive and are taught the tools that will transform their marriages. John, you'll have the details in a moment. Mm-hmm. If you want to learn more about the attachment styles,
John Fuller: you'll want to get a copy of Mark's book, Understanding Your Attachment Style. We have copies for you here at Focus on the Family. When you make a gift of any amount, we'll send you a copy as our way of saying thank you for being part of the ministry. When you partner with us financially, you're investing in families all over the world. Last year, we helped 110,000 married couples through a crisis in their relationship. The impact of that will continue for generations. And as we approach the end of the year, you have an opportunity to deliver hope and joy to families in crisis by partnering with Focus on the Family. Your generosity can help us reach even more couples and families with the biblical encouragement and practical support that they will need. That's ministry, and we'd love for you to be part of it. So please make a gift today. And right now you have an opportunity to make an even greater difference thanks to a special year-end matching opportunity. your gift will be doubled dollar for dollar, helping us reach twice as many families with the hope and the joy of the gospel. Donate today and get your copy of the book Understanding Your Attachment Style when you call 800, the letter A and the word family, or stop by focusonthefamily.com/broadcast. And by the way, if you'd like to learn more about Hope Restored, we have that information online or when you call that toll-free number. And coming up next time, a creative audio drama about the value of thankfulness, even if times are tough.
Guest (Male): Thanks to you, since you took our Thanksgiving away, we now understand the real worth of this day. We didn't ask you to show us, and we sure didn't choose it, that sometimes you don't value a thing till you lose it.
John Fuller: That's next time on Focus on the Family, and remember, when you get in touch, let us know how you're listening on our website, through our mobile app, or on our podcast feed. I'm John Fuller, and on behalf of Jim Daly and the entire team, join us next time as we help you and your family thrive.
Related Episodes
Healing Your Attachment Styles as a Married Couple – I
Thursday, November 19
How Heaven Changes the Way We See Life – II
Wednesday, November 18
How Heaven Changes the Way We See Life – I
Tuesday, November 17
Related Videos
About Focus on the Family
We want to help your family thrive! The Focus on the Family program offers real-life, Bible-based insights for everyday families. Help for marriage and parenting from families who are in the trenches with you. Focus on the Family is hosted by Jim Daly and John Fuller.About Jim Daly
Jim Daly
Jim Daly is President of Focus on the Family. His personal story from orphan to head of an international Christian organization dedicated to helping families thrive demonstrates — as he says — "that no matter how torn up the road has already been, or how pothole-infested it may look ahead, nothing — nothing — is impossible for God."
Daly is author of two books, Finding Home and Stronger. He is also a regular panelist for The Washington Post/Newsweek blog “On Faith.”
Keep up with Daly at www.JimDalyBlog.com.
John Fuller
John Fuller is vice president of Focus on the Family's Audio and New Media division, leading the team that creates and produces more than a dozen different audio programs.
John joined Focus on the Family in 1991 and began co-hosting the daily Focus on the Family radio program in 2001.
John also serves on the board of the National Religious Broadcasters.
Contact Focus on the Family with Jim Daly
Mailing Address
Focus on the Family
8605 Explorer Dr.
Colorado Springs, CO
80920-1051
Toll-free Number
(800) A-FAMILY (232-6459)